Arizona Governor Jan Brewer signed a law outlawing ethnic studies programs in her state. The law makes it illegal for a school district to teach any courses that promote the overthrow of the U.S. government, promote resentment of a particular race or class of people, are designed primarily for students of a particular ethnic group or "advocate ethnic solidarity instead of the treatment of pupils as individuals."
The history of education tells us why the multicultural ethnic studies and critical thinking approaches, held by the majority of current educators, is wrong and the culturist approach, embodied in this Arizona law, is correct.
As Arizona’s State Superintendant of Public Instruction Tom Horne put it, "Traditionally, the American public school system has brought together students from different backgrounds and taught them to be Americans and to treat each other as individuals.” The most recent issue of the American Historical Association’s newsmagazine, Perspectives on History, condemns a recent Texas law that went against the multicultural and critical theory-oriented history in textbooks. The history of education shows that the American Historical Association is wrong and the traditionalists are right.
Bernard Bailyn’s seminal history of education text, Education in the Formation of American society, shows that the Puritans emphasized education because their distance from Europe made them fear their youth would not be civilized. Ruth Elson’s masterful examination of 19th century textbooks, Guardians of Tradition, concludes, “The purpose of nineteenth – century American public schools was to train citizens in character and proper principles.” These books taught that individual virtue maintains the republic via creating economic success and altruistic voters.
Indeed our Founding Fathers often spoke of the importance of education in instilling the virtue necessary to maintaining a republic. Noah Webster created his famous dictionary with American spellings of common words in order that we might separate ourselves from the dreaded British. Benjamin Rush, signer of the Declaration of Independence included italics to make his point that, “Next to the duty which young men owe to their Creator, I wish to see a SUPREME REGARD TO THEIR COUNTRY inculcated upon them.”
R. Freeman Butts, a classic historian of education, in his 1955 Cultural History of Western Education, tells us that “culture” holds the key to understanding education. He defines it as “the whole way of life that is created, learned held in common, and passed on from one generation to another by the members of a particular society.” He shows this to be the western theme in education since our origins in the “Eastern Mediterranean World.” Indeed, historians of education in his generation routinely created global surveys going back to tribalism showing this to be the theme in education in all times and places.
As the name of their newsmagazine, Perspectives, indicates, the professional historians feel that perspectives exist rather than truths. Article after article in their May issue extols the virtue of teaching both sides of historical issues and letting students decide. And these professional historians think by critically attacking issues they can help students understand the way “real” history is made and teach real “historical” thinking. This critical approach, in the historian’s opinion, helps students see complexity, learn critical thinking skills, and, ironically, get closer to The Truth about issues.