Wednesday, February 4, 2009

The Sting of replacing Hail to the Chief is no laughing matter

There has been a lot of chuckling about Obama’s replacing Hail to the Chief with a rotation of songs that includes Sting’s “Desert Rose.” The laughing has come from people that consider it ironic that we move towards a song with Arabic content during the War on Terror. But this is no laughing matter. It is a matter of life and death. We do not see this because of the illusion of progress.

History’s seemingly straight line from tribes to chiefdoms to nation states has conspired to give us all an illusion of progress. In a certain sense there has been progress. Laurence Keeley’s “War Before Civilization” shows that in tribal times 25% of males died in battle. Wars were fought approximately once a year and every male participated. If a tribe lost too many men the women were often raped, killed or enslaved by the winning tribe. By contrast, in 20th century Europe, with its two big wars and Stalin, 1.9% of males died in battle. There was remarkably little revenge imposed on the vanquished.

Developments in political organization also reinforce the illusion of progress. Mankind writ large has moved from tribal states to ever-larger political organizations. This has brought, again, a corresponding reduction in war deaths. And these states all contain some level of infrastructure, political hierarchy, taxes, borders and military. Whereas, Kelley tells us, 66% of tribes were at war yearly, only 40% of chiefdoms had this frequency. Nation states only go to war once per generation. And so, again, we believe we see a straight line constituting progress. Certainly, many assume, these trends towards larger political units and peace mean that a globalism is destined.

The problem with assuming progress is that nation states have collapsed and large systems disappear extremely rapidly. The Roman Empire fell as much as it dissolved. Furthermore, the move towards peacefulness is registered in averages. Some chiefdoms have been extremely violent. The Aztecs and Mayans are prime examples. They went to war yearly in order to get captives for sacrifice. And some nation states have also been very brutal. Nazi Germany is the paradigmatic example in this category. But, might you not say, weren’t the Aztecs and the Nazis defeated by more peaceful political organizations? Doesn’t this prove progress? No.

Before concluding, and returning to Obama, I must point out that technology does not prove progress towards peacefulness is a natural progression either. Nazi Germany was technologically advanced. Their eugenic rhetoric was heavily informed by the theme of science. Their killing was industrial. Imperial Japan was nearly as cruel as Nazi Germany. They kidnapped young girls from all the surrounding nations and gang-raped them for years. Japan too had high levels of technology. In fact, both nations’ command of communications, transportation and weapons technology helped them in their viscous endeavors.

The problem with the assumption of progress is that the experiment is only half run. Yes, we beat both Nazi Germany and Imperial Japan. Japan’s behavior and China’s cultural revolution showed that Confucianism is not incompatible with tremendous cruelty. China is building a fierce military. More immediately, the Islamic world has declared Jihad or holy war upon us. Those who assume progress look at the fall of the Berlin wall and assume that history has ended. Conflict continues. Islamic nations and China are not buying into the idea of the destiny of cooperative globalism. Nothing is settled. America can revert back to tribal warfare. And either China or Islam may yet defeat and dominate us. The “march of freedom” does not destine global cooperative peace.

During World War Two we were famously united against our foes. We knew, as tribes in primitive warfare had to know, that our side was virtuous and the other side was evil incarnate. This knowledge led to near 100% effort by our population. Darwinian evolution does not favor the best, it favors that which is best able to survive and flourish. It may be that driven, racist, authoritarian China has more staying power than our current values based on multiculturalism can muster. More immediately, the fanatical devotion shown on the Islamic side may be able to defeat our diverse population’s nonchalant commitment to our nation. Had we been disunited and unclear about the nature of our foes in World War Two, we would have been defeated. Destiny did not lead to those victories, unity and determination did.

Obama’s saying that we are a Muslim nation during his inauguration and his adopting of an Arabic greeting for the Presidency both undermine our sense of unity and blur our ability to see good and evil. In a world with war, both the unity and erect posture Hail to the Chief engenders are very important. Furthermore Obama’s constant show of respect for Islam diminishes our understanding of why we might want to consider it our enemy. If we are unable to defeat our foes it will largely be because we are not both united and determined to defeat them. In that eventuality, Obama’s seemingly small insults to our traditions and identity will be shown to have been a matter of life and death. His adoption of a Sting song in place of a key anthem that united us will have proven to have been no laughing matter.

33 comments:

Lexcen said...

Ominous indeed.

Ducky's here said...

Cool, hope he throws in a little Oum Khartoum or Musicians of the Nile.

Maybe even some Klezmer, eh culturist?

Ducky's here said...

During World War Two we were famously united against our foes.

--------------------------

Ah no, we were initially quite isolationist and there was a very distinct pro German element.

FDR had a hell of a job provoking Japan and getting us into the war.

Unknown said...

Ducky,

Klezmer would be good!! How about a little cheer for the headhunters too!! Neither is any more - according to you - western than anything else and everything is to be equally celebrated. Hmmmnnn human cuisine!! Name it all!!!!!

The isolationists, in every reading of history I have encountered, melted when the war started. And, FDR did not know about Pearl Harbor. Have you read the MAGIC transcripts? They were clear on a concerted attempt to foment dissent among African - Americans and the existence of a widespread spy network by the Japanese. But they were vague on the details of the attack.

Revisionism and counter historicals are fun!!! I do not postulate an absolute truths. Do you? I love to try on interpretations and see what the implications are. But this is a dangerous game. We have now convinced ourselves that the West has been a force for evil in the world, even though the article I wrote shows how much more peace now exists. According to our values, peace is good.

Then again, I'm sure you'll disagree that war is bad and peace is good. That is fun! Thanks!

Ducky's here said...

I do enjoy klezmer, culturist but you must realize its roots are deeply in Middle Eastern arabic music.

Ducky's here said...

Had we been disunited and unclear about the nature of our foes in World War Two, we would have been defeated.

----------------------

I also wish to remind you that if the Russians hadn't held at Stalingrad we would have had absolutely no chance of dislodging Hitler.

The blood in Europe was Slavic. Or "barely Western" as you say in such a disgusting fashion.

Unknown said...

Ducky,

I appreciate you comment about Klezmer. Yes, it has that Middle Eastern sound. I used to play in a Klezmer group. They either threw me out because I was not Jewish enough or wanted to turn it into a experimental - jazz - Klezmer group too much.

I am sorry that you are still upset about my comment saying something like the Slavs are barely western. Again, my point was that Russia is teetering on turning back the move towards liberal democracy in that whole region. St. Petersburg may prove to have not been located West enough. I did not mean to imply that Slavic people's were not naturally progressive, great, European or whatever else you are reading into the comment.

I dearly hope that Eastern Europe continues in economic prosperity with an appreciation for rights and some form of democracy. I again, apologize for the apparent offense I apparently caused you. It was a short comment and I did not seek to besmirch the Slav's current status or potential.

John

Anonymous said...

As usual, Ducky the Persona shows up, hurls insults, offers no arguments, has no evidence, answers no criticism, contributes nothing.

FatherJack said...

You REALLY are in trouble with this clown in the white house. Here in England, we have had almost 12 years with a liberal government and they have utterly ruined everything they have touched.They pander to Islam and ignore the needs of their own people. And Obama is far more liberal than either Tony Blair or Gordon Brown. I fear for America, I truly do!

About Me said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
About Me said...

You posses a valuable insight into the maladies that plague present day America.
Most alarming is your assessment that our patriotism and nationalism are in jeopardy due to lack of responsibility amongst a confused culture. Compounding the problem is the fear that our enemies are actually more righteous and more deserving of victory. The situation is indeed dire.

Unknown said...

Zion - NJ,

Thanks for reading the post and chiming in! Indeed, not having a united patriotic citizenry weakens your international bargaining power. I fear much of California's plight stems from the same lack of affiliation with America. Many illegals send their money back home and would not side with us in another conflict with Mexico. Diversity is not always, as the multiculturalists tell us, our strength.

Dougal,

Thank you as well. I just saw your comment. I fear that what Obama is doing is worse than pandering to Islam. He seems to be actively aiding them. No sanctions on companies doing nuclear trade with Iran!!! Closing Guantanamo???? Ending our overseas CIA suspect interrogation programs?? Why??? Hopefully it is just pandering.

Culturist John
www.culturism.us

Anonymous said...

Online Casinos tyuueooru
http://stonewalljacksoncarnival.org/ - Play Casino Game
2.
[url=http://stonewalljacksoncarnival.org/]Best Online Casino[/url]
3.
Free Casino Bonus
You can enjoy online casino simply by getting connected to the Internet.

Anonymous said...

Free Casino Money tyuueooru
http://stonewalljacksoncarnival.org/ - Free Casinos
This is obvious as people can start online casino without having to make as higher investment as required to get started with land-based casino.
[url=http://stonewalljacksoncarnival.org/]Casino Bonus[/url]
No matter how far your casino is located With online casino, you don?t have to worry about the location of your casino because the only thing that creates between you and your casino experience is the internet, so all you need to do is getting connected to the Internet and you can enjoy the gambling without having to spend your time visiting the local casinos out there.
Online Casino Game
You can enjoy online casino simply by getting connected to the Internet.

Anonymous said...

Keep posting stuff like this i really like it

Anonymous said...

Damn I was going to buy a new Hummer in late 2012 and drive around the country for a vacation, Now I am going to have to shave my head and join the Hari.s, Muslims, Jews, Jehovah s, Mormons, Christians, and a few other wing nut groups just to cover all my bases.
[url=http://2012earth.net
]apocalypse 2012
[/url] - some truth about 2012

Anonymous said...

sugar daddy dating [url=http://loveepicentre.com/]dating site[/url] dreamlover mylovewebsite best international dating site http://loveepicentre.com/ free wild dating sites

Anonymous said...

What a great resource!

Anonymous said...

links to alyssa milano breast [url=http://usadrugstoretoday.com/all-products.htm]no prescription pharmacies[/url] prescription treatments for acne http://usadrugstoretoday.com/products/rocaltrol.htm philadelphia breast implant before after photo http://usadrugstoretoday.com/products/combivent.htm
hand bacterial infections soil [url=http://usadrugstoretoday.com/products/floxin.htm]floxin[/url] risk for chd and cholesterol [url=http://usadrugstoretoday.com/products/dostinex.htm]holistic antibiotics for cyst infection[/url]

Anonymous said...

http://newrx.in/levaquin/flomax-levaquin
[url=http://newrx.in/escitalopram/escitalopram-withdrawal-effects]alcohol and other drug abuse programs[/url] brand name drugs to replace ambien [url=http://newrx.in/carbohydrate/advantages-of-low-carbohydrate-diet]advantages of low carbohydrate diet[/url]
pennsylvania drug testing labs http://newrx.in/flonase/does-flonase-rase-your-blood-presure
[url=http://newrx.in/bisoprolol/ic-bisoprolol-hctz]euthanasia drugs[/url] levitra discussion [url=http://newrx.in/glimepiride/glimepiride]glimepiride[/url]
illinois law drug testing http://newrx.in/flonase/adrenal-suppression-flonase
[url=http://newrx.in/ditropan/ditropan-or-levoxyl]history of ileagel drugs marijuana[/url] emerson drug company [url=http://newrx.in/restlessness/restlessness-after-epidural-steroid-injection-forums]restlessness after epidural steroid injection forums[/url] cheap viagra cialis india [url=http://newrx.in/glimepiride/glimepiride-serum-level]glimepiride serum level[/url]

Anonymous said...

http://sk8prk.ihiphop.com/forums/viewtopic.php?f=26&t=389737 http://www.fak-online.de/phpBB2/viewtopic.php?p=946801#946801 http://tinnedmail.zoastertech.com/forums/viewtopic.php?f=13&t=46053 http://forum.heyasshole.net/viewtopic.php?f=2&t=109225
http://wiped-guild.co.uk/phpBB3/viewtopic.php?f=4&t=101232 http://thekoisource.com/forum/viewtopic.php?p=536754#536754 http://forums.risingsunajax.com/showthread.php?p=135997#post135997 http://famac.icaremalaysia.org/rmp5/index.php?topic=170491.new#new
http://www.yourmums.com/forum/viewtopic.php?p=36703#36703 http://www.reptilemagic.co.uk/forum/viewtopic.php?f=9&t=426870 http://www.hak-unwe.org/bbs//zboard.php?id=hi&page=1&page_num=5&select_arrange=headnum&desc=&sn=off&ss=on&sc=on&keyword=&no=1740&category=

Anonymous said...

quotes about the automobile in the progressive era http://autoexpress.in/royce/rolls/royce/nuclear/derby moore racing
[url=http://autoexpress.in/oldsmobile/how/rare/is/oldsmobile/final/500]hydraulic automobile power[/url] volkswagen car repair instructions [url=http://autoexpress.in/scion/turbo/for/scion/xb]turbo for scion xb[/url]
mercedes 300sdl kijiji http://autoexpress.in/oldsmobile/gm/oldsmobile/nos
[url=http://autoexpress.in/plymouth/second/hand/jetski/plymouth]volkswagen idi turbo diesel performance tuning[/url] u haul auto trailer [url=http://autoexpress.in/rally/rally/2008/photo/george/woods]rally 2008 photo george woods[/url]
new finishing line auto body products http://autoexpress.in/buell/buell/test/ride/uk
[url=http://autoexpress.in/romeo/alfa/romeo/television/commercial/sydney/2003]inflatable auto jack[/url] automobile repro [url=http://autoexpress.in/peugeot/peugeot/senlis/salt]peugeot senlis salt[/url]

Anonymous said...

nano lubricant http://planetofporn.in/first-anal/bubble-butts-anal
[url=http://planetofporn.in/erotic-stories/erotic-rape-story]hentai dbz[/url] transvite porn [url=http://planetofporn.in/girl-anal/anal-grandma]anal grandma[/url]
mature amateur orgasm videos http://planetofporn.in/ass-sex/petite-ass-galleries
[url=http://planetofporn.in/amateur-porn/youtube-free-adult-amateur]adult contents free[/url] virgin snow live action rlslog [url=http://planetofporn.in/ass-sex/black-and-latino-nude-ass-fucking-teens]black and latino nude ass fucking teens[/url]
sexy celebrity opps http://planetofporn.in/ass-video/female-ass-licking
[url=http://planetofporn.in/ass-sex/sexy-tight-ass]free thumbs porn galleries[/url] anmin porn [url=http://planetofporn.in/adult-story/homemade-adult-costume-ideas]homemade adult costume ideas[/url]
sexy dirty money http://planetofporn.in/archive-adult/imported-adult-diapers
[url=http://planetofporn.in/adult-xxx/watch-free-adult-tv-and-ponyslave]adult erotic mail order catalogs[/url] virgin birth greek mythology [url=http://planetofporn.in/erotic-gay/soppic-erotic]soppic erotic[/url]

Anonymous said...

myspace sexy christmas layout http://theporncollection.in/best-porn/witchblade-porn
[url=http://theporncollection.in/gay-porn/free-teen-gay-sex]lubricant free bearings[/url] sexy indian hardcore [url=http://theporncollection.in/gay-male/gay-white-fucking-asian-boys]gay white fucking asian boys[/url]
natural vaginal lubricants safe for pregnancy http://theporncollection.in/porn-girl/japan-porn-myfilehost
[url=http://theporncollection.in/incest/abortions-after-being-raped-or-incest]amateur free photo wife[/url] catholic anal licking [url=http://theporncollection.in/orgasm/orgasm-images]orgasm images[/url]
huge vbrating dildo http://theporncollection.in/mature-woman/mature-bukake
[url=http://theporncollection.in/masturbating/glossybabes-masturbating]sexy relatives[/url] rpg porn [url=http://theporncollection.in/incest/incest-laws-in-new-york]incest laws in new york[/url]
nsnf type adult form adhd http://theporncollection.in/gay-male/gay-and-lesbians-in-small-towns
[url=http://theporncollection.in/gay-porn/gay-doctor-fetish-videos]starwars porn cartoons[/url] sexual repression forty year virgin men [url=http://theporncollection.in/lesbian-porn/adult-lesbian-sex-storier]adult lesbian sex storier[/url]

Anonymous said...

medievil dresses and clothes http://luxefashion.us/prada-mens-leather-running-shoes-white-item2485.html italian mens fashion designers [url=http://luxefashion.us/shoes-dolce-amp-gabbana-type4.html]fashion art teen[/url] geraldine laurent
http://luxefashion.us/t-shirts-for-men-page2.html fashion men birthday gifts [url=http://luxefashion.us/34-men-size25.html]comfort foot shoes[/url]

Anonymous said...

westminster fashion http://www.thefashionhouse.us/-tank-tops-dolce-amp-gabbana-category60.html rugged shark boat shoes [url=http://www.thefashionhouse.us/44-sport-pants-size26.html]christian dior biography[/url] lauren kelley
http://www.thefashionhouse.us/dolce-amp-gabbana-women-s-tops-brand2.html lauren kritzman [url=http://www.thefashionhouse.us/?action=products&product_id=2462]mission statement interior designer[/url]

Anonymous said...

zenana outfitters clothes http://www.thefashionhouse.us/xl-evening-cocktail-size6.html victorias secret clothes [url=http://www.thefashionhouse.us/dark-turquoise-color52.html]fashion institute of design and merchandise[/url] child fashion model photo
http://www.thefashionhouse.us/casual-page12.html african fashion [url=http://www.thefashionhouse.us/dsquared-dress-shirts-brand13.html]hippopatumus shoes[/url]

Anonymous said...

best bingo online http://xwn.in/keno_free-internet-keno-slot-machines casino de monte carlo
[url=http://xwn.in/poker-online_printed-poker-cards]write off lottery ticket losses ohio[/url] jackpot arizona state numbers break lunch lottery web [url=http://xwn.in/baccarat_baccarat-system-ubs-ultimate]baccarat system ubs ultimate[/url]
florida lottery numbers october 13 http://xwn.in/online-casinos_map-of-casinos-in-las-vegas
[url=http://xwn.in/gambling-online_facts-and-fugures-gambling]barrie bingo[/url] email lottery [url=http://xwn.in/joker_mark-hamill-joker-interview]mark hamill joker interview[/url]
li partnership housing lottery in south hampton http://xwn.in/jackpot_chingy-chingy-jackpot-ring blackjack demo [url=http://xwn.in/joker_joker-big]joker big[/url]

Anonymous said...

retro nike basketball shoes http://topcitystyle.com/red-women-s-tops-color8.html fanco s shoes [url=http://topcitystyle.com/frankie-morello-on-sale-brand19.html]gangster fashion[/url] lauren hill gallery
http://topcitystyle.com/gant-casual-brand112.html shoes and stockings [url=http://topcitystyle.com/blumarine-casual-brand53.html]floershem shoes[/url]

Anonymous said...

discount automobile batteries http://xwm.in/acura/acura-tl-mirror-switch-2004 play online car racing games
[url=http://xwm.in/freightliner/freightliner-windshield]automobile tire wear bars[/url] auto door lock malfunction [url=http://xwm.in/chrysler/chrysler-dodge-jeep]chrysler dodge jeep[/url]
mercedes c300 4matic 2008 review http://xwm.in/rover/diesel-conversion-land-rover
[url=http://xwm.in/racing/sim-racing-china]mercedes 300 sport wood kit[/url] sportinglife racing sunshine [url=http://xwm.in/dodge/headlight-replacement-instructions-for-dodge-dakota]headlight replacement instructions for dodge dakota[/url]
automobile ltd in singapore http://xwm.in/saleen/saleen-motors
[url=http://xwm.in/opel/opel-corsa-lite-power-increase]price of auto lpg[/url] auto chem [url=http://xwm.in/audi/vendita-audi-a5]vendita audi a5[/url]

Anonymous said...

free blackjack game for pocket pc http://lwv.in/lottery/pensylvania-lottery blackjack internet gambling
[url=http://lwv.in/betting/where-can-i-find-the-betting-spread-for-nfl-games]college football betting tips[/url] casinos effect on small businesses [url=http://lwv.in/casino-playing-cards/sports-playing-cards]sports playing cards[/url]
what is ppx wv lottery http://lwv.in/casino-playing-cards/fit-deck-playing-cards
[url=http://lwv.in/poker-online/bar-poker]suncoast casino[/url] illinois lottery [url=http://lwv.in/jackpot/rosstown-hotel-carnegie-trivia-jackpot-question]rosstown hotel carnegie trivia jackpot question[/url]
gambling casinos new york state http://lwv.in/online-casino blackjack ncaa cell phone cover [url=http://lwv.in/jackpot/jackpot-party-slot-machines]jackpot party slot machines[/url]

Anonymous said...

and then there were none movie spin off [url=http://moviestrawberry.com/films/film_relentless_enemies/]relentless enemies[/url] power of one movie http://moviestrawberry.com/films/film_lost_boys_the_tribe/ the last ride movie
twists of fate the movie [url=http://moviestrawberry.com/films/film_the_secret/]the secret[/url] turner movie classics http://moviestrawberry.com/hqmoviesbyyear/year_1995_high-quality-movies/?page=4 japan movie
haven the movie [url=http://moviestrawberry.com/films/film_back_to_gaya/]back to gaya[/url] song of an innocent bystander movie
movie times for randhurst [url=http://moviestrawberry.com/films/film_journal_of_a_contract_killer/]journal of a contract killer[/url] the lizziemdguire movie http://moviestrawberry.com/films/film_noise/ most popular movie stars
lake in i walk the line movie [url=http://moviestrawberry.com/films/film_the_tigger_movie/]the tigger movie[/url] artic tale movie http://moviestrawberry.com/films/film_cheech_chong_s_next_movie/ black dahlia movie

Anonymous said...

the williamsburg music hall [url=http://mp3-s.co.uk/all_music-daniele-e-viviana-127519-1/]Daniele E Viviana[/url] rocky road to dublin music score http://mp3-s.co.uk/all_music-scuba-19-1/ the kraken sheet music
business college degree music university [url=http://mp3-s.co.uk/all_music-the-deeper-sound-of-mimi-kesaris-10975-1/]The Deeper Sound of Mimi Kesaris[/url] vietnam war country music http://mp3-s.co.uk/all_music-storm-troopers-26-1/ tv shows music theme
free country radio music [url=http://mp3-s.co.uk/all_music-ina-a.-williams-120204-1/]Ina A. Williams[/url] hornpipe from watermusic sheet music
downloadable music sheets god bless the broken road [url=http://mp3-s.co.uk/all_music-bert-kaempfert-and-his-orchestra-77069-1/]Bert Kaempfert and His Orchestra[/url] play backwards reverse music http://mp3-s.co.uk/all_music-sx01-16-1/ queen buy music dvd
charmed season 5 music [url=http://mp3-s.co.uk/all_music-bizzy-bone-featuring--titus-179891-1/]Bizzy Bone featuring Titus[/url] alicia keys music lyrics http://mp3-s.co.uk/all_music-technical-itch-34-1/ music schools california